The Israel-Palestine conflict is a deeply complex and multifaceted struggle that has persisted for over a century. The issues at the heart of this conflict touch on territorial disputes, religious significance, and the basic human rights of the people involved. In this second part of our series, we will explore five main problems that continue to fuel this seemingly intractable conflict, as well as the challenges and potential paths forward.
1. The Border Dispute
At the core of the Israel-Palestine conflict is the question of borders. Both Israelis and Palestinians lay claim to the land, but there is no consensus on how it should be divided. The United Nations’ 1947 partition plan aimed to establish separate Jewish and Arab states, but this division has never been fully accepted by either side. The result has been decades of conflict over territorial claims, with each side insisting on its right to the land.
The lack of agreement on borders has led to numerous confrontations and wars, and to this day, the borders remain a contentious and unresolved issue. The Israeli settlement expansion in the West Bank has further complicated the situation, as it encroaches on what is internationally recognized as Palestinian land.
2. The Settlement Construction
One of the most significant sources of tension between Israelis and Palestinians is the construction of Israeli settlements on Palestinian territories. These settlements, which are illegal under international law, have expanded steadily over the years, displacing Palestinian residents and fragmenting the land that could potentially be part of a future Palestinian state.
For Palestinians, these settlements are a direct violation of their rights and a major obstacle to peace. They see the ongoing expansion as an attempt by Israel to solidify its control over the West Bank and make the establishment of a viable Palestinian state impossible. On the other hand, many Israelis view the settlements as a security measure or a fulfillment of historical and religious rights to the land.
3. The Status of Jerusalem
Jerusalem is a city of profound religious significance for Jews, Muslims, and Christians alike. For Jews, it is the location of the Western Wall, the last remaining part of the Second Temple and the holiest site in Judaism. For Muslims, it is home to the Al-Aqsa Mosque, the third holiest site in Islam. Christians revere it as the place of Jesus’ crucifixion and resurrection.
The status of Jerusalem is one of the most sensitive issues in the conflict. Both Israel and Palestine claim the city as their capital, but there is no agreement on how it should be shared. The international community has long proposed that Jerusalem be treated as a special international city, but this idea has never been fully implemented. The city’s religious and historical significance makes it a focal point of nationalist and religious fervor, complicating efforts to find a peaceful resolution.
4. The Right of Return for Palestinian Refugees
The issue of Palestinian refugees is another deeply contentious aspect of the conflict. During the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, approximately 750,000 Palestinians were displaced from their homes. These refugees and their descendants, now numbering in the millions, have long sought the right to return to their former homes in what is now Israel.
Israel has consistently opposed this right of return, arguing that allowing millions of Palestinians to return would threaten the Jewish character of the state. Instead, Israel has suggested that these refugees should settle in the future Palestinian state. This remains a point of major disagreement, with Palestinians insisting on their right to return as a fundamental aspect of any peace agreement.
5. The Water Dispute
Water is a precious and scarce resource in the arid region of the Middle East, and the control and distribution of water have become a significant issue in the Israel-Palestine conflict. Israel, located in a desert environment, has developed extensive water infrastructure, including the control of key water sources in the region.
Palestinians accuse Israel of restricting their access to water, exacerbating the already dire living conditions in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The struggle over water resources is emblematic of the broader territorial disputes, with each side accusing the other of unfair practices and exploitation.
The Role of Religion and Ideology
While the Israel-Palestine conflict is often viewed through the lens of territorial disputes, religion plays a critical role in shaping the ideologies and actions of both sides. For many, the conflict is not just about land but also about fulfilling religious destinies and preserving sacred sites. However, this intertwining of religion and politics raises the question of whether religion is being exploited to justify actions that might otherwise be seen as unacceptable.
In both Judaism and Islam, religious practice is closely tied to daily life, making it difficult to separate religion from political and social issues. This has allowed religious ideologies to play a central role in the conflict, particularly for groups like Hamas, which, driven by a combination of religious and nationalist motivations, has engaged in armed struggle against Israel. Hamas, declared as a terrorist organization by the EU and the United States, seeks not only the liberation of Palestine but also the establishment of a society governed by its interpretation of Islamic law.
The Challenges of Secularization and Dialogue
One possible path toward resolving the conflict lies in the secularization of politics and the separation of religion from state affairs. In many Western countries, religion is considered a private matter, allowing for more inclusive and pluralistic societies. However, the deep religious roots of both Jewish and Palestinian identities make this separation particularly challenging in the context of the Israel-Palestine conflict.
A critical aspect of moving forward involves fostering dialogue and building a civil society that transcends religious and nationalistic divides. Unfortunately, the current situation is marked by segregation, with little interaction between Israeli and Palestinian communities. This lack of contact only serves to entrench stereotypes and foster mistrust, making the prospects for peace even more remote.
Looking Forward: Building a Future Beyond Conflict
The path to peace in Israel and Palestine is fraught with obstacles, but it is not entirely hopeless. For any lasting solution to be found, both sides must commit to building civil societies that prioritize dialogue, education, and mutual understanding. This requires not only political will but also significant support from the international community.
One potential approach is to revisit the idea of making Jerusalem an international city, protected by international law and open to all religious practices. Such a solution could help preserve the city’s religious and cultural heritage while reducing tensions over its status.
Moreover, the future of Gaza and the West Bank hinges on the development of robust societal structures that can support a peaceful and prosperous existence. The international community, including Israel, must invest in the reconstruction and development of Palestinian territories to provide a foundation for a stable and sovereign Palestinian state.
Conclusion
The Israel-Palestine conflict is one of the most challenging and enduring conflicts of our time. Its roots are deep, and its consequences are profound, affecting millions of lives. While the issues at stake—borders, settlements, Jerusalem, refugees, and water—are complex, they are not insurmountable. The key to resolving this conflict lies in the willingness of both Israelis and Palestinians to engage in meaningful dialogue, supported by the international community, and to envision a future where peace and coexistence are possible.
The road ahead is difficult, but it is imperative that we continue to seek solutions that respect the rights and aspirations of both peoples. Only through mutual recognition, respect, and cooperation can a lasting peace be achieved in this deeply troubled region.
Sources
TV2- 7th oktober 2023, URL: https://nyheder.tv2.dk/udland/2023-10-07-israel-palaestina-konflikten-forstaa-hvorfor-de-slaas
TerraX History, “Kampf um Palästina – Wie der Konflikt begonnen hat I Terra X”, 21th january 2024, URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_oMRGmAgaY
MrsWissen2go – 2018, URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HjRnr3AfFo
Zeit Online, “Israel, Palästina, Hamas: Wie der Nahost-Konflikt gelöst werden könnte”, 23th november 2023, URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P6TSQRCPsPE
SRF Kultur Sternstunden, “Israel & Palästina: Der ausweglose Konflikt im Heiligen Land | Sternstunde Religion | SRF Kultur”, 31th oktober 2023, URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1aIcTsw1Ek
SternTV, “7 Tage Israel-Gaza-Krieg – auf der Suche nach Frieden | stern TV”, 28th march 2024, URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H0EltnbGm-g
URL: https://www.aljazeera.com/ – Provides in-depth reports from the Middle Eastern perspective, including current events and historical context.
Council on Foreign Relations, “Are Israel and Iran Headed for All-Out War?”-July 31, 2024, URL: https://www.cfr.org/expert-brief/are-israel-and-iran-headed-all-out-war
Council on Foreign Relations, “What is Hamas?”-August 19, 2024, URL: https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/what-hamas
The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territoriers, URL: https://www.btselem.org/
Landeszentrale für politische Bildung – Baden Wüttenberg, “Der Nahostkonflikt”, June 2024, URL: https://www.lpb-bw.de/nahostkonflikt
